Log In


Reset Password

Lehighton board to address budget transfers

Lehighton Area School District will bring a list of budget transfers to the school board for a vote later this month, the first formal response to a board member’s claim that the district has been spending past its budgeted lines in violation of state school code.

Superintendent Jason Moser told the board last Monday night the transfers will appear as a voting item at the November legislative meeting, and that they will be positioned on the agenda ahead of the payment of bills.

“We will be preparing a pretty exhaustive list of necessary budget transfers,” Moser said. “The time to get that done for tonight was pretty tight considering the timing of our board meeting.”

Placing transfers before bills payable is the procedural fix. The sequence lets the board confirm money exists in an account before approving payments drawn against it.

“If there were any necessary transfers to ensure that there was money in those accounts, they would be there before voting on the bills,” Moser said.

He told the board transfers would come on an as-needed basis, potentially monthly, though he said frequent transfers would signal a problem of their own.

“We would hope that they’re not monthly, because that means you have a lot of areas where you did not plug money into the budget line, or at least the correct budget line,” he said.

In a separate change, the board voted 8-1 in a straw poll to shift the district’s monthly financial report to a true end-of-month cutoff. Board member David Bradley cast the lone dissent.

Under current practice, the district closes its books on a date chosen for proximity to the board meeting rather than the calendar.

“We pick a fairly arbitrary cutoff date, which happens close to the legislative meeting, and we run it up to that,” Moser said. “It’s not truly an end of month. It’s still live in that regard.”

Beginning with the November meeting, the report would cover through Oct. 31, with bills payable listed separately so members can see the effect of what they are approving.

“You can gauge what that impact is code by code, based upon what you’re voting on to actually pay,” Moser said. “One of the benefits would be that it makes reconciling the monthly financial report to the condensed report a little bit easier, because it would be looking at the same time frame at the same cutoff date.”

He said the transition would create a one-time gap of roughly two weeks and nothing after that.

“There would never actually be a lapse,” he said.

Bradley objected that a government operating on a cash basis should be looking at current figures, not closed ones.

“You should never have a report that is anticipating what happened in the past,” he said. “It should be current, because you’re making decisions based upon current data. If not, you’re cornering next month’s report to whatever already happened.”

His larger argument was that the district has already broken the law. Bradley cited Sections 609, 687 and 218 of the Pennsylvania School Code, and said a 2020 state performance audit had flagged the same issues.

“All three of these were written up in the state performance audit in 2020, when we called in the state auditor,” Bradley said. “At which point he admonished this district specifically for 609. We should have learned the lesson by now, but we’re still repeating the same mistake.”

The exchange widened into the district’s unfiled annual financial report, which was due to the state Oct. 31. Moser said he will not sign the certification until auditors verify the numbers.

“I cannot sign off on that statement that says these numbers have been audited and verified,” he said. “I will not do that until I get that from the auditor, because that’s my commission. I’m at risk if I sign that document.”

He said the figures themselves are not in question.

“Do I think it’s accurate? Yes, I have every reason to believe it’s accurate,” Moser said. “Has it been verified? No, it has not.”

The district is operating under an automatic 30-day extension that runs to Nov. 30, which Moser said exists because missing the October deadline is routine statewide.

“The reason PDE has an automatic extension through Nov. 30, to my best understanding, is because they know that nobody gets it done by then,” he said.

He also said the district has little leverage over its auditors.

“There’s not a lot of money in public school audits, to be honest, so a lot of these auditing firms aren’t jumping at the bit,” Moser said. “The last time we bid, my understanding is we got one auditing firm who bid on our job.”

Removing that firm (Barbacane, Thornton & Company LLP) over a missed October deadline, he said, would leave the district with none. He said he had previously worked in a district running a year and a half behind on its annual financial reports.

Director Denise Hartley pushed back on Bradley’s framing that the board had shrugged off the deadline.

“Nobody here has used the word ‘it’s O.K.’ ” she said. “It is not available because the audit has not been completed. Because it cannot be signed off on, it cannot be submitted. That does not mean we’re willing to not do it. It means we cannot lawfully do it. We also have an obligation to the public to do things correctly — not just to do them, but to do them properly and correctly.”