Log In


Reset Password

Dec. 17 confirmed for data hearing

The date for a curative amendment hearing filed for a data center in Lower Towamensing Township will not be changed despite pleas from residents earlier this month to move the hearing until after the holidays.

The hearing for DTA Alliance will be held at 6 p.m. Dec. 17 at the Aquashicola Fire Company.

Contacted Friday, township zoning officer Duane Dellecker said that the zoning office has provided a list of adjoining owners to the applicants, and DTA must now send them out to all adjoining property owners.

Dellecker said there are 85 properties on the list that must receive notification of the curative amendment hearing by certified mail.

“In the next week, I will post the properties that are going to be subject to the hearing,” Dellecker said. “But, I do not

think the hearing will be closed out in one night of hearings; I suspect there will be at least one or more continuances.”

Earlier this month, close to 100 residents filled the Lower Towamensing supervisors meeting room to request the date of the curative amendment hearing be moved to after Christmas so more people may participate.

The proposed data center developers, DTA Alliance LLC and Murphy’s Meadow LLC, are the owners of the Alliance Sand Quarry.

Murphy’s Meadow is owned by DT Allen Contracting in New Jersey, and has 368 acres under contract, including the Blue Shamrock Golf Course.

The proposal in Lower Towamensing encompasses the Blue Shamrock Golf Club and land at the sand quarry, and is proposed to be adjacent to Fireline Road, housing in Bowmanstown, and Princeton and Edgemont Avenue in West Palmerton. There are 14 buildings planned over 700 acres with a total footprint of 4.5 million square feet.

The buildings range in size from 125,000 square feet to 650,000 square feet.

Warehouse zoning

About 50 residents attended Thursday’s township planning commission meeting where Dellecker presented his review letter to the planning commission.

Dellecker wrote that DTA Alliance has filed a curative amendment to the township zoning ordinance, stating the ownership has failed to permit a data center use anywhere within the township and proposes a curative amendment to allow for data centers as a use permitted within an overlay over the R-R (Resort and Recreation) & R-C (Rural Conservation) zoning districts.

Dellecker compared the data center to a warehouse and said the zoning ordinance defines a “warehouse” as “a structure uses for storage only, of equipment and merchandise; while another section of the zoning ordinance addresses “Uses not specifically provided for.”

Subsection A acknowledges that no zoning ordinance can regulate all possible uses of land or anticipate all future conditions. This section allows a particular use in a district if the use is not materially different from other uses allowed in that district, and if the proposed use will not create adverse effects to a degree materially greater than other uses permitted in the district.

The ordinance provides for zoning officer approval if the use is similar to a permitted use and zoning hearing board approval if the use is similar to permitted special exception uses.

A warehouse would be a principal use in the industrial zoning district.

“It is the opinion of this office that a data center, as a facility used for storage of computer systems and equipment, is materially similar to a warehousing use,” Dellecker states in his review letter. “This use is allowed in the industrial district as a permitted use.”

The appeal argues that the term “industrial park” and “warehouse,” although they are defined in the zoning ordinance, are not listed within the table of use regulations as permitted anywhere.

“Warehousing as a principal use” is listed within the tables of use regulations found in Section 450, Attachment I of the zoning ordinance. This use is permitted in the Industrial zoning district.

“Even though the traffic demands and operations of a data center may be different from that of a warehouse, as a warehouse is materially similar to a data center, a structure used for equipment storage, it is the opinion of this office that the zoning ordinance is not exclusionary.” Dellecker states in his letter.

The proposal is to create an overlay district, allowing data centers in the R-R an R-C zoning districts. The response is that Section 450-19 of the zoning ordinance outlines the purpose of each zoning district.

The purpose of an R-R District is to provide for commercial developments consisting of a combination of transient and permanent housing accommodations and commercial indoor and outdoor recreational and entertainment uses which serve as a destination for vacationers and those attending conferences or conventions as well as those partaking of these activities for a shorter duration.

The purpose of an R-C District is to maintain the rural character of this sparsely developed area predominantly in farmland and woodland, to encourage the preservation of the agricultural and woodland resources of the township.

“It is the opinion of this office that the proposal does not meet the purpose or intent of either the R-R or the R-C zoning districts and is not remotely similar to any permitted uses in either zoning district,” Dellecker said. “As the use is determined to be similar to that of a warehouse, under Section 450-26 of the zoning ordinance, the appropriate procedure would have been to apply for a variance to allow for the data center use in the R-R and R-C zoning districts.”

A hearing for DTA Alliance will be held at 6 p.m. on Dec. 17. TIMES NEWS FILE PHOTO