JT ice cream vendor loses license appeal
Jim Thorpe Borough Council denied an ice cream vendor’s appeal of his revoked merchant license Thursday, but left a path open for the business to return in 2027.
Justin Hydro, who operates Smokeshows Nitro Ice Cream at 20 W. Broadway, challenged the revocation in a hearing that ran more than an hour and in which he asked that three council members disqualify themselves.
Council asked Hydro and the property owner to jointly submit a formal waiver request under Chapter 333 of the borough code for consideration next year.
Councilman Lyle Augustine voted no on the appeal denial. Councilwoman Alice Roberti declined to vote at all.
“I don’t agree with the full decision,” Roberti said.
Council President Connor Rodgers, Vice President Mike Yeastedt, Councilwoman Joanne Klitsch and Councilman Mike Hartman voted to deny.
Recusal request
Hydro opened the hearing by asking that Rodgers, Yeastedt and Councilwoman Joanne Klitsch step aside, reading a written motion into the stenographic record that cited the 14th Amendment and Lyness v. State Board of Medicine, a 1992 Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling barring administrative bodies from mixing prosecutorial and judging roles.
He alleged Yeastedt had conducted unannounced field inspections of his business alongside Borough Manager Maureen Sterner, and that Sterner emailed Yeastedt in late May seeking enforcement input on custom permit conditions.
He accused Rodgers of blocking the property owner’s representative from being recognized on council agendas and of serving on a closed-door zoning map subcommittee that altered boundary designations affecting his address while his dispute was pending.
Klitsch, he said, sat simultaneously on the planning commission, council and that same subcommittee, and voted in April to exclude his parcel from the commission’s commercial recommendation.
“An official who effectively participates in altering the zoning classification of property during an active dispute cannot act as an impartial judge over a permit dependent on that exact zoning designation,” Hydro said.
Solicitor James Nanovic put the question to each member and noted the arithmetic.
“I hope you also understand that if you have three people recuse themselves, we’ll have less than a quorum, which means you’ll have a deemed denial,” Nanovic told Hydro.
All three declined to recuse themselves.
Background
The borough issued Hydro a transient merchant license May 26 and revoked it weeks later. A June 9 letter from borough office administrator Lisa Herman said the license had been granted “due to an error on the part of the administrative staff,” and attributed it to her misunderstanding of the ordinance requirements.
The provision at issue bars transient retail business “from a fixed location other than from areas designated as being zoned commercial.”
Hydro’s case turned on that wording.
“In every communication that we received from the borough, they twisted those words and they made the ordinance say that we are not in a residential zoning district,” he said. “Now, we are most certainly in a zone designated commercial.”
His central exhibit was Ordinance 77-13, adopted Dec. 8, 1977, which extended the C2 commercial district along the north side of West Broadway using the former First Presbyterian Church property as a boundary marker. That building now houses the Anita Shapolsky Art Foundation on the property where Hydro’s stand operates.
“This is the law of the land,” he said of the ordinance, which he said has never been repealed. He also produced a 1987 zoning permit listing the site as being commercially zoned, a Carbon County commercial property record card, and the borough’s own 2017 zoning map disclaimer stating that locations “should be considered approximate.”
Before testimony, Hydro moved to dismiss the appeal outright, saying the borough had already lost on the same ordinance section in magisterial district court on Sept. 21 after a full trial.
“The borough cannot lose a full trial in a court of law and then force a citizen into a parallel administrative hearing where the borough acts as both prosecutor and judge to relitigate the exact same issue,” he said.
Nanovic’s response was three words: “It’s not dismissed.”
Hydro also demanded a refund of the $1,000 hearing fee. He said he filed a written appeal June 22 after Klotz told him there was no specific form, and that the borough created a new appeal form four days later and reclassified his filing as a formal hearing. He objected that Nanovic took part in that decision while standing to collect a share of the fee. He paid after a July email warned the borough would presume he was no longer interested, writing “paid under protest, paid under duress” across the check.
Called as a witness, Sterner said no one had complained about the business.
“There was not a complaint,” she said. “It was a review of the application, and it was discovered that it was not in the proper zoning district.”
She said staff can find violations on their own.
“We have code officials here at the borough. That is part of their job.”
Neither she nor Assistant Borough Manager Brooke Klotz could say who directed Herman to make the initial June 5 call.
Klotz said it was “either myself or Maureen,” and that such a direction would have been given verbally.
When Hydro turned to the borough’s ongoing zoning map revisions, Nanovic stopped him.
“This is not a fishing expedition,” the solicitor said. “Whether or not the borough is changing its zoning ordinance has nothing to do with the current status of the zoning ordinance.”
Hydro’s attempt to call council members as witnesses was also refused, because they were sitting as judges.
Neighbor support
Two neighbors spoke in his favor. Brian Evans, who lives next door at 24 W. Broadway, said the art foundation building cannot realistically be used for anything but commercial purposes, and warned that zoning it residential could doom it.
“You could be damning that building to never be used again,” Evans said. “It has not been perfect, but any time that we’ve had anything, any issue at all, they have been very responsive. I’m their neighbor, and I’m telling you, it’s not a problem.”
Tim Duncan said the stand draws visitors up Broadway and away from the congestion downtown.
“The church is clearly a commercial district. It’s a museum, for God’s sakes,” Duncan said. “It honestly doesn’t feel right that the art museum can continue being a business, but (Smokeshows) can’t be a business literally in front of them.”
Hydro’s partner, Tara Osborn, was sworn in and described a custom trailer held at port for three years over mislabeled customs tags, a $50,000 storage bill the family could not pay, and banks that turned them away before a community-backed loan let the business open in 2024.
“It was the people of Jim Thorpe who saved us,” Osborne said. “If we are forced to close our window, it doesn’t just end a small business. It crushes our family’s livelihood. I paid $1,000 just to have the chance to speak to you tonight.”
Nanovic noted that the license at issue runs only through the end of the year.