Log In


Reset Password

Appeals court upholds conviction of former Monroe financial planner

The U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday upheld the conviction and sentencing of a former Monroe County financial planner convicted of defrauding clients, the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Pennsylvania said.

Anthony Diaz, 54, formerly of East Stroudsburg, was convicted by a jury on multiple counts of wire fraud and mail fraud and sentenced to 17 and a half years in jail on March 26, 2021, by U.S. District Court Judge Malachy E. Mannion.

According to U.S. Attorney Gerard M. Karam, from approximately 2008 through April 2015, Diaz owned and operated Financial Planners Group of America, a financial planning business in East Stroudsburg and Scotrun.

Diaz persuaded his clients to invest in high risk, illiquid “alternative investment products,” including real estate investment trusts, business development companies, oil and gas drilling companies, and equipment leasing companies.

Diaz convinced clients to invest their life savings in the alternative investments through a series of false representations, including that the investments were low-risk, with guaranteed protection of principle and guaranteed rates of return, and that the investments were liquid, giving investors access to their funds in an emergency.

Diaz challenged his conviction and sentence, prompting the judge to remark, “On appeal, parties sometimes throw everything against the wall to see what sticks. Here, nothing does.”

The Court of Appeals found that the government properly presented evidence of the full scope of Diaz’s scheme to defraud, including conduct occurring after the wires and mailings that were specifically charged in the indictment.

Evidence showed that Diaz was terminated by five broker-dealers and permitted to resign by a sixth broker-dealer.

Diaz’s former employees testified that they were ordered to conceal his firings and lie to the clients about his changes between broker-dealers.

Diaz also was suspended by the Certified Financial Planners Board of Standards in 2013, and under investigation by the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority and the Pennsylvania Department of Banking, both of whom ultimately barred Diaz from the securities industry in 2015.

Diaz’s clients testified that he failed to disclose and concealed the true nature of his firings, suspension, and regulatory investigations.

The Court of Appeals upheld the admission of that evidence, finding the concealment of such information from clients to be intrinsic to Diaz’s offenses.

The Court of Appeals upheld a sentencing enhancement imposed by the District Court for defrauding at least 25 victims, holding that although the district court did not specifically identify each victim at sentencing, it was entitled to draw reasonable inferences from the record in support of the enhancement.