Log In


Reset Password

Pleasant Valley looks at cafeteria options

The Pleasant Valley School District is weighing its options for food management - outsource or keep in house.

The school board plans to convene today for a special meeting at 6 p.m. today to discuss a contract with Whitsons Nutrition LLC and eliminate the director of Food Services position with the district.

The reason for the change is because business manager Michael Simonetta and Superintendent James Konrad said the district’s food service department has been running at a loss for several years and now has a $1.4 million deficit.

At the school board meeting on Thursday, Simonetta said the district might make a profit by switching to a food service management company because it won’t have to pull out an extra $40,000 a year to cover additional expenses, and the district is now 100% qualified for Community Eligibility Provision.

According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, the Community Eligibility Provision “is a non-pricing meal service option for schools and school districts in low-income areas. CEP allows the nation’s highest poverty schools and districts to serve breakfast and lunch at no cost to all enrolled students without collecting household applications.”

School board director Todd Kresge asked Simonetta about the cafeteria fund, what it covers and how it is budgeted.

All of the food services expenses come out of one fund, Simonetta said.

“We transfer over whatever we need,” he said.

“So they’re basically self-sufficient, but like equipment repairs, and salaries, and benefits, all comes out of cafeteria,” Kresge said.

Simonetta said they are required to record all expenses related to the cafeteria.

Director Robert Clark asked if salaries and benefits were included in the proposals from the outside food management companies. Simonetta said they are listed as School Food Authority costs. That number was $714,884.

Simonetta said the district provided to the companies the SFA and the district’s cafeteria revenue number, which was $1,560,252, so all of the proposals had the same starting point. Four companies submitted proposals.

Simonetta and his committee consisting of school board director Diane Serfass and assistant business manager Tammy Smale selected Whitsons was the best choice.

Whitsons provides food service to the Easton Area School District and Quakertown Community School District, Simonetta said. Before coming to PVSD, he was the business manager in Easton.

The other three companies included Aramark, Nutrition Group and Chartwells, which is the provider at the Monroe Career and Technical Institute, Pocono Mountain School District and Stroudsburg Area School District, Simonetta and Serfass said.

“I’ve worked with both companies over the years. I have a personal preference and perspective,” Simonetta said. He thinks Chartwells has struggled to make the profit for school district that they promise to make.

“To try to get there, they ended up sacrificing quality, variety, and they also did staffing limitations to try to reach that number in my experience,” he said.

Chartwells is promising a $225,000 profit to the school district, as long as the subsidy from the state doesn’t go below the 2022-2023 reimbursement rate, Simonetta said. Whitsons says it can provide a $25,635 profit without any subsidy from the federal government to the state.

“We know that the rates for next year are going to be reduced significantly,” he said.

During the pandemic, the government increased the reimbursement, but that level is dropping back down next school year by 40 cents per lunch and 15 cents per breakfast, Simonetta said.

“For PV, that’s approximately $160,000 of reduction in reimbursements. Whitsons accounted for that in their guarantee note,” he said.

Whitsons also promised to use locally sourced ingredients at least 50% of the time, and have the meals cooked from scratch. In addition to hiring a food director, they want to hire a culinary director to work with the food service employees to teach them how to make the meals from the start.

Simonetta said all the district’s food service employees would remain, except for the current director of the Food Services Program, Beverly Hendricks. She would be laid off, but could apply for the director position with the outside food management company.

The contract with Whitsons would be renewed annually for four years, but changes could be made if the district wants to add or subtract something from it.

In other local districts, Lehighton and Jim Thorpe are managed by Nutrition Group. Metz Culinary Management Inc. handles Palmerton.