Log In


Reset Password

Catholic legislators feeling church's ire

Rep. Nick Miccarelli, a Delaware County Republican, said he was shocked to learn that the weekly bulletin at his church mentioned that he had voted for the bill.

"I've been to Iraq and back and there's very little that makes my jaw drop, but seeing that in parish bulletin, my jaw hit the floor," said Miccarelli, who served two tours in Iraq in the Army National Guard. "I was in disbelief."Under the headline "JUST SO YOU ARE AWARE" the announcement reads, "State Representative Miccarelli voted in favor of House Bill 1947, which states that private institutions can be sued as far as 40 years ago for millions of dollars, while public institutions may not be sued for any crimes."Last weekend, a letter by Archbishop Charles Chaput was given to all 219 archdiocese parishes urging parishioners to ask their senators to vote against it.Explaining why the archdiocese opposes the bill, Chaput wrote that potential lawsuits would unfairly affect schools and parishes that had nothing to do with the long-ago abuse. He also said the financial ramifications could cripple the ministry.The House overwhelmingly approved the bill in April, and it is now being considered by the Senate. It would allow people who say they were abused as children to bring civil lawsuits until they turn 50, up from the current age limit of 30. It also would prevent organizations from claiming immunity if they are found to have acted with gross negligence.Similar legislation is pending in New York and New Jersey, with temporary windows to file the claims. The Pennsylvania proposal has no end date.Other states have opened similar windows. In May, Minnesota's three-year window closed for victims of long-ago childhood sex abuse to file lawsuits. In that time, more than 800 people brought abuse claims against churches, the Boy Scouts, schools and a children's theater company. Two Roman Catholic dioceses filed bankruptcy and the heightened scrutiny played a part in the downfall of two bishops.Chaput successfully fought similar legislation in Colorado over a decade ago when he was Denver's archbishop.David Clohessy, executive director of Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, sees Chaput's tactics in Pennsylvania as an "escalation in scale.""He's targeting more lawmakers now, which suggests he's more afraid," Clohessy said.Archdiocese spokesman Ken Gavin said priests simply shared public knowledge."The bill is public and the voting records are public," he said.