Headed to trial
A Weatherly district judge on Thursday found sufficient evidence to send involuntary manslaughter and related charges against a man who suffers from dementia to Carbon County Court.
District Judge Joseph D. Homanko Sr. made the ruling following a preliminary hearing for Carl L. Smith, who lives at Weatherwood Nursing Home and Rehabilitation Center, but is currently housed in the Carbon County Correctional Facility.Smith, 53, is accused of pushing another patient, Margaret R. Lechleitner, 85, at 7:15 p.m. April 20, in the nursing home. Lechleitner died at Hazleton General Hospital six hours after she fell backward and hit her head.Smith is also charged with simple assault and recklessly endangering another person. He was charged by Weatherly police on May 18, and jailed under $150,000 bail.Smith was represented by attorney Stephen Vlossak Sr., of Palmerton. Carbon County Assistant District Attorney Michael S. Greek is prosecuting the case.Homanko denied Vlossak's request to drop the charges.According to an affidavit of probable cause filed by Weatherly Sgt. Mike Bogart, here's what happened:Emergency units were called to the nursing home at about 7 p.m. on April 20 for a fire in the elevator control room. Workers had been told to start evacuating the building. Shortly after, staff workers were told the fire was out, and to bring the residents back in.Licensed practical nurse Dourene Strittmatter had been assigned to work Area Two that day, and was in the area of the lounge and recreation room, or "sub dining room," as the staff called it.She told police she counted the residents in Area Two after they had been brought back in. Strittmatter said she went to the sub dining room door, near the nurses' station. She said she didn't open the door because a resident was in front of it, but that she looked through a window and saw Lechleitner calmly standing in the dining room, away from the door to the hallway.The affidavit says Strittmatter told police she walked back into the hallway, checking on residents, and ended up back at the dining room, by the door, less than a minute later. She saw Lechleitner standing in front of Smith, about four feet away from him, waving her finger at him.Although she could not hear what they were saying, it looked to Strittmatter as if the two were arguing.Strittmatter saw Smith push Lechleitner with both hands. Lechleitner fell straight backward, "like a board," Strittmatter said, hitting her head on the floor.Strittmatter immediately ran to Lechleitner's aid. As she was on her knees next to the elderly woman, Smith walked over, reached down and grabbed Lechleitner's right arm, trying to pick her up. He pulled her upper body up from the floor, asking "are you OK," Strittmatter said.Strittmatter cradled Lechleitner so that her head would not hit the floor again, and told Smith to not touch her. Strittmatter then left Lechleitner in the care of certified practical nursing assistant Katherine Kunkel, so she could go for help.Kunkel told police she had seen both Lechleitner and Smith prior to the incident, and that both had been calm. She said that she had seen the two in the dining room, and that Lechleitner was pointing her finger at Smith. Kunkel could not hear what Lechleitner was saying, however. Kunkel also saw Smith push Lechleitner, and said Lechleitner fell straight back onto the floor.Lechleitner was taken by ambulance to Hazleton General Hospital, where a CT scan showed massive bleeding in the right side of her brain. Lechleitner was pronounced dead at 1:37 a.m.An autopsy, performed at Wilkes-Barre General Hospital at 11:30 a.m. April 22 by forensic pathologist Gary Ross, determined that the cause of death was a subdural hematoma resulting from falling after being pushed, and that the manner of death was homicide.