Log In


Reset Password

Jim Thorpe will survive, with or without Jim Thorpe

Make no bones about it: The businesses of Jim Thorpe will survive if the revered Olympian's remains are shipped to Oklahoma, his birthplace.

The battle over Thorpe's remains, which has moved to the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals, will determine whether his body will be shipped back to a reservation in Oklahoma to be buried or stay at a memorial site in the town named for him.Thorpe's son, John Thorpe, sued the borough in 2010 under the provisions of the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act. John Thorpe was joined by his brothers Richard and William Thorpe in the suit. The brothers won the lawsuit which gives Thorpe's tribe, the Sac and Fox Nation of Oklahoma, the right to take back his remains as the court has classified the town as a museum since it has accepted federal funds.James Francis "Jim" Thorpe, a world-class athlete who died in 1953, was raised as a Native American, and his ethnicity played a role in the championship sports he played and in his status as an Olympian. What was formerly Mauch Chunk and East Mauch Chunk became Thorpe's home, and was merged and renamed Jim Thorpe after the area acquired the athlete's remains from his third wife in 1953. Thorpe's wife had been angry that the state of Oklahoma would not agree to build a memorial in her husband's honor, and designated the body to the area after local officials agreed to build a monument for Thorpe there.Now that the borough is appealing the judgment that was issued by federal Judge Richard Caputo on April 19 in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, the question is whether tourist revenue that the town depends on will be diminished without the Olympian.Mike Guy of Rainbow's End, a candy store and ice cream parlor on Broadway, does not believe removing Thorpe's body from the town will have an effect on his business."We've been here 16 years. Not that many people come here looking for a memorial," he said.Guy said he thinks people come to Jim Thorpe for the outdoor activities such as hiking and rafting that the town has to offer, a thought shared by Randall Sellers, owner of Sellers Used Books & Fine Arts."There's a lot besides the bones that this town stands for now," said Sellers, referring to Jim Thorpe's outdoor and cultural assets.Sellers had originally lived in South Philadelphia, and moved to the area after a visiting the area on a whim. His decision to move to Jim Thorpe and later start his business in the town had nothing to do with Jim Thorpe, the athlete.The majority of the visitors to the town do not come because of the memorial.Nancy Zeigler, manager of the Broadway Inn and Grille, said only a handful of people come a year to see Thorpe's memorial. Connie Bowman-Visniski, front desk secretary at the Inn, added that most of their visitors are not even aware of Jim Thorpe's memorial being in town until they are already here and looking for something to do.Zeigler does not think the removal of Thorpe's body will have an impact on the Inn."We were a hotel long before the town was named Jim Thorpe," said Zeigler.Whatever the final resting place, it is widely agreed that the town name should remain Jim Thorpe, regardless of whether or not the town is still hosting the Olympian's remains.Having Thorpe's body here and changing the name of the town is what Darren Behan, head chef of Molly Maguire's Irish Restaurant & Pub, believes put the town on the map. Yet, as time has gone by, Behan said people have begun to recognize the town for a variety of other reasons."The town has now come up with its own identity," said Behan, who believes the restaurant will not be affected by the court's decision.The town's identity also derives from other historical sites and recreational activities. The Old Jail Museum, Mauch Chunk Opera House, and the Harry and Asa Packer Mansions are all historical sites in town. There also is the Old Mauch Chunk Train Station and Lehigh Gorge Scenic Railway Inc., which attract tourists in the fall season who come to ride the train and admire the area's foliage.Businesses such as Pocono Biking, Pocono White Water, Jim Thorpe River Adventures, Whitewater Rafting Adventures, and Blue Mountain Sports have also attracted tourists to the area for recreational reasons.Marianna Monteleone, owner of an original clothing design store and the Bed & Breakfast alternative "Suites on Broadway," could not predict what might happen to her business but offered a realistic view on the situation."Any publicity about the town, whether good or bad, is still publicity. The more the name is out there, the more that people will know it is a tourist attraction," she said.Monteleone believes that the court's decision will not change what the town has to offer."Do you think people will stop coming to a beautiful town because the person it is named for is moved back to Oklahoma?" she asked.No one knows just what will happen to Jim Thorpe's remains after the appeal. For now, he isn't going anywhere soon. Which is good the town is celebrating his birthday this weekend, and what's a birthday party without the birthday boy?

Darren Behan, head chef of Molly Maguire's Irish Restaurant & Pub, will keep smiling and cooking up local favorites no matter what happens to Jim Thorpe's remains.